Skip to content

How we calculate

The comparison tool adds up the fees a broker would charge you over one year for your profile, then ranks the brokers from cheapest to most expensive. These are the rules, with no hidden formulas.

01Our methodology

The order is the result of a calculation, and only cost counts: no weighting, no scores, no opinions. The calculation is not done by artificial intelligence: a program applies fixed, public rules, the same for every broker, and anyone can redo the calculation by hand. With the same data, the calculation always gives the same result.

Every figure has a source and a date. Most come from the brokers' official documents. When a broker does not publish a figure, we fill it in with fixed rules, and the result details show where it comes from (see “When a figure is missing”).

When a rule leaves room for doubt, we take the most cautious option for you: the one that does not make a broker cheaper unless a source says so.

Every rule change raises the methodology version. The result shows the version used, so it is clear which rules each ranking was calculated with.

We do not publish opinions about brokers or user ratings: those are opinions, not data with a source and a date.

02The 7 costs we include

  • Brokeragethe commission on each order, at the broker's standard online price, with its minimums, maximums and price bands, without promotions. For funds, the broker's subscription commission. If the broker gives a brokerage credit every quarter, it is deducted, up to that quarter's brokerage, with nothing carried over. Exception: with automatic purchases every month (monthly saver), the broker's savings plan, if it covers what the profile buys and is cheaper.
  • Charges per orderwhat is added to each order. The broker's own charges and, on a separate line for each market, the third-party fees it charges on top (exchange, clearing, regulators). Also fixed charges per transaction for real-time data, when the broker charges them.
  • Custody feesaccording to the broker's price list, with its minimums, maximums and surcharges, and VAT if it applies, on the average portfolio over the year (your capital plus, on average over the year, what you have already bought: purchases spread over the year, with no change in prices). Also, on a separate line, what the broker charges to pay out each dividend.
  • Currency exchangethe broker's margin to convert your CHF into the market's currency on each purchase, and dividends in a foreign currency into the account currency (assumption: the ETF distributes).
  • Stamp duty, VAT and other taxesthe client's share of the Swiss stamp duty (half the legal rate), when a Swiss securities dealer is involved. VAT at the legal rate on the fees that Swiss law or the broker's official source makes subject to VAT, when the price does not include it; it is shown with each fee. The excess US withholding tax, if the broker does not apply the reduced treaty rate. And, if you buy on these markets, the taxes on purchases in France, Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom, and Hong Kong stamp duty.
  • Account and inactivityaccount maintenance fees, and inactivity fees using each broker's own definition applied to your profile. Also the Swiss tax statement: counted as an annual fee unless the broker says it is only charged on request (the sample profiles do not request it). For a cross-border commuter, the surcharge for living outside Switzerland.
  • Deposits and withdrawalswhat the broker charges for CHF transfers into and out of the account.

The total is the sum of the seven items. Each item is rounded to the centime, and the breakdown is always shown.

03Your profile

You enter your capital, the number of purchases per year, the average amount per purchase, what you buy (ETFs, shares or investment funds) and the share of your purchases on each market.

Each purchase becomes one order on each market in your split, for that market's share of the amount. Example: a purchase of CHF 1,250 split 50% Switzerland and 50% United States gives two orders of CHF 625. The number and size of orders matter, because minimum fees per order, fixed fees per order and price bands depend on them.

The calculation covers three situations. If you live in Switzerland, or are an expat living in Switzerland, the fees and the result are the same; for an expat, the result says so.

If you are a cross-border commuter (you live in France, Germany, Italy or Austria and work in Switzerland), the calculation uses the broker's fees for cross-border commuters when it publishes them, otherwise those for residents, with a notice. Surcharges for living outside Switzerland that the broker publishes are counted. If a broker charges a different fee to “certain jurisdictions” without saying which, we count the higher of the two. If its official source says it does not accept cross-border commuters (or those from your country), it is not ranked. No tax of your country of residence is calculated.

If you choose investment funds, subscribed through the broker off-exchange, the split by market and the positions per market do not apply: each purchase is a subscription.

04The sample profiles

Seven sample profiles serve as examples. All live in Switzerland. Four only buy ETFs; the fund saver subscribes investment funds through the broker, off-exchange; the crypto and gold savers buy directly from the broker. In the comparison tool, you can enter your own figures.

ProfileCapitalPurchases/yearPer purchaseMarkets
BeginnerCHF 5'0004CHF 1'25050% Switzerland50% United States
Monthly saverCHF 20'00012CHF 50050% Switzerland50% United States
InvestorCHF 100'0006CHF 2'90030% Switzerland20% Germany50% United States
Active traderCHF 50'00060CHF 2'00020% Switzerland20% Germany60% United States
Fund saverCHF 20'00012CHF 500Investment funds (off-exchange)
Crypto saverCHF 5'00012CHF 250Crypto
Gold saverCHF 10'0004CHF 1'000Precious metals
Try these profiles in the express comparison

05Crypto and gold

For crypto and gold, we compare buying directly from the broker, not ETFs or derivatives on these assets. The two model profiles: 12 crypto purchases of CHF 250 a year for a CHF 5,000 portfolio, and 4 gold purchases of CHF 1,000 a year for a CHF 10,000 portfolio.

The annual cost adds up the purchase commission, the broker's margin on the price (the gap between the price paid and the market price), currency exchange, custody fees and other account fees. The crypto margin is measured on bitcoin; for another cryptocurrency it may differ. No source says which currency the purchase is made in: we calculate in CHF and in USD and keep the more expensive. Stamp duty does not apply: the law covers neither crypto nor metal bought directly.

VAT: the purchase commission on crypto and metal is counted with VAT at the standard rate (a calculated figure, as no source makes it clear). Physical gold of at least 995 fineness is exempt under the VAT Act; gold in a metal account without a right to delivery is counted at the standard rate.

When a broker does not publish its margin, we calculate it and the figure is flagged: for crypto, from the cost published by a reference bank (LUKB) minus its commission, or from the gap between published buy and sell prices; for gold, with the highest official figure among the other brokers. A broker with no total cost for this profile appears after the others, without a total.

06The ranking order

  • The lowest total yearly cost comes first. Nothing else goes into the order.
  • If two totals are equal to the centime, the brokers share the same rank and are listed alphabetically.
  • Brokers without a total cost for your profile come after the others, in alphabetical order, and are not compared with a partial figure; their profile remains available on the “Brokers” page.
  • A broker has no total cost in two cases. Either it does not say it offers what you buy (including when it does not offer it online, only through another channel), except in the case described under “When a figure is missing”. Or a figure is missing: we then show the known sum as a minimum (“from … CHF”), with what is missing.

07Conversion to CHF

Fees in euros, US dollars, pounds or Hong Kong dollars are converted into francs with the European Central Bank (ECB) reference rate, updated automatically every business day.

If the rate is 6 to 10 days old, the comparison says so. From 11 days, amounts that need a conversion are not calculated.

ECB reference rates of 17 November 2026

  • 1 EUR0.9233CHF
  • 1 USD0.8402CHF
  • 1 GBP1.1083CHF
  • 1 HKD0.1071CHF

Source: European Central Bank (ecb.europa.eu). Updated automatically every business day.

08When a figure is missing

Each figure is filled in in this order and labelled with its origin. First, the broker's official source (or the law), with the date it was checked. If the broker does not publish the figure, the one from Moneyland or, failing that, the one from two comparison sites that give a similar figure, labelled “comparison-site figure”, with its link and date. Otherwise, a figure calculated with a fixed rule of our methodology, labelled “calculated figure”, with its method. A comparison-site figure or a calculated figure never replaces an official one.

A calculated figure can be, for example: the median of the official figures of brokers of the same type (banks with banks, online platforms with online platforms); the official fee of an exchange, a clearing house or an authority, as it publishes it itself or as another broker publishes it; the exchange margin worked out from the rates the bank itself publishes; or 0, when the broker's source says these fees are covered elsewhere, or when our methodology sets it that way, with a notice that the real cost may be higher.

When neither the official source nor comparison sites say whether the broker offers the product on a market, we count the highest cost over the year (fee per order × your orders, plus yearly fees) among brokers of the same type (banks or online platforms) that offer it with a published figure (or, if there are fewer than two, also with a calculated figure), labelled “calculated figure”, so that a broker is never cheaper because of an assumption. If it does not offer it, it would have no total cost for your profile (not ranked).

When the official source leaves room for doubt (two figures that contradict each other, or several fees without saying which one applies): if the documents state the date they take effect and cover the same product, plan and company, the newer one prevails. Otherwise, if Moneyland uses one of the official figures, we take that one. Otherwise, we take the highest of those that can apply to your profile, labelled “calculated figure” with the reason.

Third-party fees that the broker charges on top (exchange, clearing, authorities) are added for every broker, with their source. If the broker does not give the amount, they are filled in in the same order and labelled with their method.

If a broker does not publish whether it charges inactivity fees, they count as 0, with a notice: the profiles place several orders a year.

Comparison-site figures and calculated figures count in the total and the ranking, so the real cost may differ. If none of these steps gives a figure, the broker has no total cost for your profile: we never present a partial sum as a total, nor a 0 in place of a missing figure, except the cases of 0 described above, flagged with a notice.

09Our assumptions

  • You place your orders online, at the broker's normal rate: a market order, in continuous trading, with no promotions or special offers, except the broker's savings plan for automatic purchases every month (see “Brokerage”).
  • If a broker offers several plans: when the plan depends on an amount (deposit or assets), the one that matches your capital at the start of the year; when you can choose freely, the cheapest with a complete cost for your profile, plan fee and third-party fees included; when the conditions of the other plans are not published, the basic plan. A plan whose total relies on a figure calculated from other brokers' data does not go ahead of a complete plan that does not need one. The result details always show the plan calculated.
  • The sample profiles buy in Switzerland, Germany and the United States. With your own figures, you can also choose France, Italy, the Netherlands, Spain, the United Kingdom and Hong Kong.
  • Purchases in Switzerland are calculated on SIX Swiss Exchange and those in Germany on Xetra; other exchanges may have a different price. If a broker does not publish the fee for an exchange, we use the one for its other exchanges in the same market, with a notice.
  • What you buy: an ETF domiciled outside Switzerland (also on the Swiss exchange); on Xetra, an EU UCITS fund; in the United States, a US fund. This decides the stamp duty (the rate for foreign securities) and the custody surcharges for a foreign domicile. It is the most cautious option: with a Swiss ETF, the real cost would be slightly lower. For shares, the company is assumed to be from the market's country.
  • For fees charged per share in the United States, the price of one share is assumed to be USD 100.
  • Unless you enter something else, you hold one position per market where you buy; what is bought on the Swiss exchange is held in Switzerland, the rest abroad; you make one CHF transfer a year into the account and no withdrawals. If the broker charges a percentage of deposits, we assume you deposit each year what you buy.
  • The account is in CHF and currency exchange happens automatically on each purchase in another currency; a conversion you request separately is not calculated. If a broker's account is not in CHF, the calculation starts from its currency (the CHF transfer also pays its exchange); if it is not clear which account currency is possible, we count the most expensive one for the profile. The result says so.
  • The ETF pays its dividends in four payments a year, at the dividend yield of the MSCI index of its market, on the average portfolio over the year. This is a calculation assumption, not a forecast. It is used to count the exchange on dividends, the fees for paying them out and the excess US withholding tax. Without an exchange (investment funds), there are no dividends.
  • Thresholds (free account above a certain amount of assets, plan by deposit size, account fee by asset band) are checked with the capital at the start of the year: it is the lowest portfolio of the year. If the broker measures the portfolio on fixed dates, the real cost may be higher, and the result says so.
  • The fund saver subscribes a Swiss equity fund, in its CHF class (no currency exchange), which has a distribution agreement with the broker, held in Switzerland, as a single position. The issue of Swiss funds is exempt from stamp duty. Each assumption is flagged in the result.
  • Swiss stamp duty relies on two provisional readings, pending a legal opinion: a Swiss broker passes its half on to the client, and the duty is counted as 0 when no Swiss securities dealer is involved. The result says so.
  • Taxes on purchases in France, Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom are calculated at the legal rate. For shares, we assume a company from that country, above the legal threshold; in Italy, the full rate, because it is not known where the broker executes the order. For ETFs: 0 in France, where the law excludes them; in Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom, the rate for shares, because their exemption is not clear. In Hong Kong, the legal stamp duty applies to shares; ETFs are exempt.
  • If a broker announces new prices without publishing the figures yet, we calculate with today's prices, and the result says so.
  • Not included: sales (the profile only buys); fees charged by the funds themselves (TER, management fee, issue or redemption commissions of the fund), excluded in the same way for everyone, with an information line outside the total on the TER of ETFs; withholding tax on dividends at the treaty rate (15% in the United States, the same for every broker); purchases on credit, algorithmic orders, short sales and other orders outside the profile; a conversion requested separately, closing the account, securities transfers, the bank's own products and promotions.

10How the site is funded

Today no broker pays us: the site has no income and no commercial agreement.

Later, the site may receive a commission when someone opens an account through one of our links (an affiliate link). That commission will never go into the calculation or the order: a broker that pays and one that does not are ranked by the same rules. What each one pays will be published on this page.

11Our sources

Most fees come from the brokers' official documents: we keep their page or document, with the date it was checked, and every figure links to its source.

Exchange fees can also come from the official fee published by the exchange itself, or by another broker that publishes it with its amount. Legal rates come from the legal texts and the federal administration, exchange rates from the ECB and dividend yields from the official MSCI index factsheets.

When a broker does not publish a fee, the figure comes from a comparison site or a calculation, labelled as such: see “When a figure is missing”.